top of page

Does 1 Corinthians 4:6 Teach Material Sufficiency?

Oct 28
22 min read

Updated: Oct 28

First Corinthians 4:6 has been at the center of many debates over sola scriptura, and honestly, I think that's understandable. After all, the apostle Paul explicitly instructs the Corinthians to learn "not to go beyond what is written" (1 Corinthians 4:6, LSB). On the surface, that certainly seems to lend some pretty strong support to the Protestant understanding of Scripture's authority.


However, I've noticed that some Protestant apologists tend to make this verse say far more than it actually says, almost as though Paul's statement establishes the entire doctrine of sola scriptura in one go. And while I understand why someone might be tempted to make that argument, I don't think that's the best way to approach Scripture.


But I think we need to be equally careful about making the opposite mistake. Just because a passage doesn't establish an entire doctrine by itself doesn't mean it offers no meaningful support for that doctrine.


And I think that's particularly important when discussing 1 Corinthians 4:6.


Before we go any further, though, we need to clarify what we're actually trying to establish.


Sola scriptura teaches that Scripture is the Church's only infallible rule of faith. However, when discussing the sufficiency of Scripture, theologians commonly distinguish between material sufficiency and formal sufficiency.


Now, those terms might sound complicated, but the distinction is actually pretty simple.


Material sufficiency asks whether Scripture contains everything God has permanently obligated Christians to believe, whether explicitly or by legitimate implication.


Formal sufficiency, on the other hand, concerns whether Scripture is sufficiently clear and adequate to function as the Church's rule of faith without requiring another infallible interpreter.


For our purposes, we're going to focus specifically on material sufficiency. We're not attempting to prove every aspect of sola scriptura from this one passage.


Instead, I want to investigate a question that I think deserves considerably more attention: What if the strongest argument for material sufficiency isn't found in the isolated wording of 1 Corinthians 4:6, but in the larger argument Paul has been developing throughout the preceding chapters?


Because I think that when we carefully follow Paul's reasoning, paying attention not only to what he explicitly states but also to the theological implications of his argument, we discover a compelling case for the material sufficiency of Scripture.


And that's the argument I want to examine in this article.


What Exactly Was Paul Correcting?


Before we can understand what Paul means in 1 Corinthians 4:6, we first need to understand the problem he was addressing. And thankfully, Paul doesn't leave us guessing.


In 1 Corinthians 1:10–12 (LSB), Paul confronts the Corinthians over divisions that had developed within their congregation. Some were identifying themselves with Paul, others with Apollos, others with Cephas, and still others with Christ. And as we continue reading, it becomes clear that these divisions weren't simply disagreements over which teacher they preferred. The Corinthians had begun elevating certain Christian ministers above others, creating rivalry and arrogance within the Church.


But here's a question worth considering: What exactly was wrong with the Corinthians' evaluations of these ministers?


After all, there's nothing inherently wrong with appreciating one Christian teacher more than another. We all have teachers whose preaching or explanations we find particularly helpful. So the problem couldn't simply have been that the Corinthians had different preferences.


Rather, the problem was that they were evaluating God's servants according to the wrong standards.


Throughout chapters 1 and 2, Paul contrasts the wisdom of God with the wisdom of the world. The Corinthians had become preoccupied with human wisdom, status, and rhetorical ability, allowing these things to distort their understanding of Christian ministry. But Paul reminds them that God's wisdom doesn't operate according to worldly expectations. In fact, what the world considers foolish is often precisely what God uses to demonstrate his power (1 Corinthians 1:18–31).


And what's particularly interesting is how Paul goes about correcting their thinking.

Rather than simply telling the Corinthians to stop dividing themselves, Paul repeatedly appeals to Scripture to demonstrate why their judgments are mistaken.


For example, in 1 Corinthians 1:19, Paul quotes Isaiah 29:14 to demonstrate how God overturns human wisdom. In verse 31, he draws from Jeremiah 9:23–24 to remind them that boasting belongs in the Lord. Then, in 1 Corinthians 3:19–20, he appeals to Job 5:13 and Psalm 94:11 to further demonstrate the foolishness of worldly wisdom before God.


Notice what's happening here. Paul is using written Scripture to correct the theological standards by which the Corinthians are evaluating Christian ministers.


But Paul doesn't stop there. He also begins explaining what Christian ministry actually involves.

In 1 Corinthians 3:5–9, he describes himself and Apollos as servants through whom the Corinthians believed. Paul planted, Apollos watered, but God was responsible for the growth. Neither minister was supposed to become the center of attention because both were simply carrying out the work God had entrusted to them.


Then, beginning in verse 10, Paul compares Christian ministry to the construction of a building. Jesus Christ is the foundation, and those who build upon that foundation must be careful how they build. Paul even explains that the quality of each person's work will eventually be tested (1 Corinthians 3:10–15).


Now, I think that's significant because Paul is no longer simply identifying the Corinthians' divisions. He's explaining the actual responsibilities of Christian ministers and the standards by which their work will ultimately be evaluated.


And surely, that work includes their doctrine. After all, Christian ministers build up the Church in significant part through their teaching and proclamation of the gospel. But it also includes how they conduct themselves and fulfill the responsibilities entrusted to them.


And this becomes even clearer when we arrive at chapter 4.


In 1 Corinthians 4:1–2, Paul describes Christian ministers as servants of Christ and stewards of God's mysteries. He then identifies what is required of a steward: faithfulness.


And I want us to pay particular attention to that word, because it tells us something important about how Christian ministers ought to be evaluated.


The question isn't whether a minister is impressive, popular, or particularly eloquent. The question is whether he's faithful to what God has entrusted to him.


But notice what Paul says immediately afterward.


In 1 Corinthians 4:3, Paul explains that he considers it a very small thing to be examined by the Corinthians or by any human court.


Now, examined for what exactly?


Well, given what Paul has just said about stewards being required to demonstrate faithfulness, the natural answer is that Paul is discussing the evaluation of his own faithfulness as a minister of Christ.


And that's a much broader question than which Christian teacher happens to be someone's favorite.


Think about it. If we're examining whether a minister has been faithful to the responsibilities God has entrusted to him, wouldn't that necessarily involve his teaching? Wouldn't it also involve his conduct and the manner in which he's carried out his ministry?


Of course it would.


Now, Paul is also careful to establish an important limitation here. In verses 4–5, he explains that even his own clear conscience doesn't constitute his final acquittal. The Lord himself is the ultimate judge, and he will reveal even the hidden motives of the heart.


So Paul isn't suggesting that human beings are competent to pronounce the final verdict on a minister's faithfulness. Quite the opposite. He's reminding the Corinthians that their judgments are limited and that God's judgment is ultimately decisive.


But that doesn't mean Christians are incapable of evaluating what a minister openly teaches or how he conducts himself. Rather, Paul is distinguishing our limited human evaluations from the final and comprehensive judgment that belongs to God.


And I think this progression is important.


The Corinthian divisions may have prompted Paul's discussion, but his correction has developed into a much broader explanation of Christian ministry, what faithfulness requires, and the limits of human judgment.


Paul hasn't abandoned the original problem. He's addressed the underlying assumptions that produced it.


The Corinthians needed to understand that Christian ministers aren't celebrities competing for admiration. They're servants entrusted with God's work, and their faithfulness cannot be measured by the worldly standards the Corinthians had been using.


That's the larger argument Paul has been developing throughout these chapters.


What Does Paul Want the Corinthians to Learn?


Now that we've examined Paul's argument, I want us to pay particular attention to what he says in 1 Corinthians 4:6 (LSB). After spending several chapters correcting the Corinthians' understanding of Christian ministry, Paul explains why he has been using himself and Apollos as examples.


He says that he has applied these things to himself and Apollos for their benefit, "so that in us you may learn not to go beyond what is written." He then identifies the intended result: that the Corinthians would no longer become arrogant in favor of one person against another.


Now, I think there's something particularly important about how Paul structures this statement, because he doesn't simply tell the Corinthians to stop dividing themselves. Instead, he explains what he wants them to learn from everything he's been teaching them.


And what exactly does he want them to learn? Not to go beyond what is written.


In fact, Paul uses two purpose clauses here. The first identifies what the Corinthians are supposed to learn, while the second identifies the desired outcome of that instruction.


New Testament scholar Mark Keown makes this observation in his article, "Do Not Go Beyond What Is Written" (1 Cor 4:6), published in Stimulus in 2015. On page 45, Keown explains how Paul's two successive purpose clauses communicate what he intends to accomplish through his examples.


And I think recognizing this distinction is important because it raises a question: If Paul's only concern were that the Corinthians stop dividing over Christian ministers, why does he specifically instruct them to learn not to go beyond what is written?


Now, obviously, Paul wants the divisions to stop. That's not in dispute. But notice that he's addressing the underlying problem that produced those divisions in the first place.


The Corinthians had been evaluating Christian ministers according to worldly standards. Paul corrected those evaluations by appealing to Scripture, explaining the responsibilities of ministers, and reminding the congregation that God is ultimately the one who judges their faithfulness.


So when Paul instructs them not to go beyond what is written, I think the natural implication is that Scripture establishes the boundaries for the theological judgments they're authorized to make concerning God's servants.


Interestingly, the nineteenth-century Protestant theologian Charles Hodge makes a similar observation in his Commentary on the First Epistle to the Corinthians. Commenting on verse 6, he writes:


"The Corinthians were not to think of their ministers more highly than the Bible authorized them to think."

I think Hodge captures the central issue remarkably well. The Corinthians weren't simply arriving at unfortunate conclusions about particular ministers. Their judgments were exceeding what Scripture actually authorized.


And notice the distinction here, because I think it's an important one.


There's a difference between making a judgment that doesn't explicitly contradict Scripture and making a judgment that Scripture actually warrants.


For example, suppose someone argues that a particular Christian minister is more faithful than another because he's a better public speaker. Now, recognizing that someone has exceptional speaking abilities isn't inherently wrong. But does that ability establish that he's a more faithful minister of Christ?


Of course not.


If we're going to make a theological judgment about someone's faithfulness before God, we need a theological standard that actually justifies that judgment. We can't simply elevate our own preferences into divinely authorized criteria.


And that's the principle I believe Paul is teaching.


But there's another question we need to consider: What exactly does Paul mean by "what is written"?


Admittedly, this expression has generated considerable discussion among biblical scholars. Some understand Paul to be referring specifically to the Old Testament passages he's already quoted, particularly those concerning worldly wisdom and boasting. Others understand the expression more broadly as a reference to Scripture.


Personally, I think the immediate context gives us good reason to understand Paul as referring to Scripture. After all, throughout his argument, Paul has repeatedly introduced Old Testament quotations with the expression "it is written." Those quotations have played an important role in establishing why the Corinthians' judgments were mistaken.


However, I don't think we necessarily have to choose between recognizing those particular passages and understanding Paul to be teaching a broader principle.


The quotations establish why the Corinthians' judgments were wrong. But the lesson Paul draws from his argument concerns the boundaries of their theological evaluations.


The immediate application of a principle doesn't necessarily exhaust everything that principle entails.


And this distinction also matters when considering how Paul's instruction relates to the New Testament.


Obviously, Paul was writing before the New Testament canon was completed. So we shouldn't pretend that he was explicitly referring to a completed collection of twenty-seven New Testament books.


Nevertheless, if the principle concerns the authority of God's written revelation, why would that principle stop applying when additional inspired revelation was committed to writing?


Keown makes this very point on page 47 of his article, explaining that the continuing application of Paul's instruction includes:


"the apostolic writings of the New Testament including those of Paul."

And that makes sense, especially when we remember that Paul himself recognized the divine authority of his written apostolic instructions. In 1 Corinthians 14:37 (LSB), he explicitly identifies what he writes to the Corinthians as the Lord's commandment.


So while the Old Testament provides the immediate background for Paul's instruction, the underlying principle can reasonably be applied to inspired Scripture more generally.


And that's why I believe 1 Corinthians 4:6 is so significant.


Paul has spent several chapters correcting the Corinthians' theological evaluations of Christian ministers. He has grounded his correction in Scripture, explained what faithful ministry actually involves, and identified the limitations of human judgment.


Then, in verse 6, he tells them what they should learn from his argument: Don't go beyond what is written.


In other words, Christians must not presume to impose theological judgments concerning spiritual faithfulness that exceed what God's written revelation authorizes.


That's the principle I believe Paul establishes in this passage.


Does This Principle Lead to Material Sufficiency?


Now, I think this is where the theological implications of Paul's argument become particularly interesting. Because if Paul is instructing the Corinthians not to go beyond what is written when evaluating Christian ministers, we need to ask ourselves an important question: Why would this principle apply to the evaluation of Christian ministers but not to the Christians those ministers are responsible for teaching?


Think about that for a moment.


Christian ministers are responsible for teaching, shepherding, and building up the Church. So would it make sense for Scripture to establish the boundaries by which we evaluate the faithfulness of those ministers, while allowing us to impose additional, unauthorized theological standards upon the Christians they're leading?


I don't see why that distinction would follow.


Now, obviously, Christian ministers have responsibilities that ordinary Christians don't. Scripture itself establishes additional qualifications for those who oversee God's people (1 Timothy 3:1–7, LSB). But the fact that ministers have additional responsibilities doesn't mean the underlying principle concerning legitimate theological judgments suddenly stops applying when we move from the shepherds to the sheep.


Interestingly, the seventeenth-century biblical commentator Matthew Poole recognized that Paul's instruction had implications for the entire congregation. In his commentary on 1 Corinthians 4:6, he describes its intended audience as:


"all the church of Corinth, as well ministers as people"

Now, Poole was specifically discussing the humility the Corinthians needed to learn, so I don't want to suggest that he was making our entire argument for material sufficiency. Nevertheless, his observation is helpful because it recognizes that Paul's instruction was intended to shape the thinking of the entire congregation.


But here's something even more important: We don't actually need to move beyond Paul's discussion of Christian ministers to arrive at material sufficiency.


Let me explain.


Remember what Paul established in 1 Corinthians 4:1–3 (LSB). Christian ministers are servants of Christ and stewards of God's mysteries. And what is required of a steward? Faithfulness.


Paul then immediately discusses being examined by the Corinthians.


And as we established earlier, the natural question is: Examined for what?


Well, given the context, Paul is discussing the evaluation of his faithfulness as a minister of Jesus Christ.


Now, let's consider what that actually involves.


What does it mean for a Christian minister to be faithful?


Surely, part of that faithfulness involves accurately teaching and preserving the doctrines God has entrusted to his Church.


In fact, Paul makes this connection explicitly elsewhere. In 1 Timothy 4:16 (LSB), he instructs Timothy to pay close attention to both himself and his teaching. Likewise, in Titus 1:9 (LSB), Paul explains that an elder must hold firmly to the faithful word so that he can both encourage others through sound doctrine and refute those who contradict it.


So evaluating a minister's faithfulness necessarily involves evaluating his doctrine.


And interestingly, we see the Corinthians struggling with this very issue again in Paul's second letter.


In 2 Corinthians 10:12–18 (LSB), Paul criticizes those who measure themselves by themselves and compare themselves with one another. He then reminds the Corinthians that the person who ultimately matters isn't the one who commends himself, but the one whom the Lord commends.


Sound familiar?


But in 2 Corinthians 11:4–6 (LSB), Paul also addresses their willingness to tolerate someone proclaiming another Jesus or a different gospel. And notice that he specifically contrasts his supposed lack of rhetorical skill with his knowledge.


In other words, the Corinthians were still struggling to properly evaluate Christian ministers, and Paul once again directs their attention away from outward impressions and toward matters of genuine theological importance.


Now, here's where I want us to think carefully.


Suppose a Christian minister openly denies the resurrection of Jesus Christ. Wouldn't that be relevant to evaluating his doctrinal faithfulness?


Of course it would.


In fact, Paul himself explains in 1 Corinthians 15:12–19 (LSB) that denying Christ's resurrection carries devastating consequences for the Christian faith.


Or suppose a minister begins proclaiming a fundamentally different gospel from the one the apostles preached. Wouldn't that also constitute doctrinal unfaithfulness?


Again, Paul explicitly condemns such teaching in Galatians 1:8–9 (LSB).


Now, notice why these examples matter.


We're not introducing some unrelated theological subject. We're still discussing the evaluation of Christian ministers, which is precisely what Paul has been addressing throughout 1 Corinthians 3–4.

And these examples demonstrate that doctrinal faithfulness is an essential part of faithful Christian ministry.


But let's take that reasoning one step further.


If God has permanently obligated Christians to believe a particular doctrine, wouldn't a minister's knowing rejection of that doctrine be relevant to evaluating his doctrinal faithfulness?


I think the answer is clearly yes.


After all, we're not talking about someone's personal theological preferences. We're talking about something God himself has supposedly required Christians to believe.


And if God has genuinely established that obligation, then a minister who knowingly repudiates it is rejecting something he's supposed to uphold.


This leads us to an important conclusion: Every permanently binding Christian doctrine can, in principle, become a legitimate standard for evaluating a Christian minister's doctrinal faithfulness.


Now, I want you to recognize what we've just established.


We're still operating entirely within Paul's discussion of Christian ministers. We haven't had to introduce an unrelated subject or stretch his argument into some completely different context.


We've simply asked what evaluating a minister's faithfulness actually entails.


And the answer necessarily includes the doctrines that God has obligated Christians to believe.


So now let's apply the principle Paul establishes in 1 Corinthians 4:6.


If we're instructed not to go beyond what is written when evaluating Christian ministers, how could we legitimately condemn a minister for rejecting a doctrine that cannot be established from what is written?


I think that's a question we really need to wrestle with.


Because remember, there's a difference between something not explicitly contradicting Scripture and something having sufficient scriptural warrant to be imposed as a divine requirement.


Let's use an example.


Suppose someone believes that the veneration of religious icons is a divinely revealed doctrine that Christians are obligated to affirm.


Now imagine a Christian minister who openly rejects the legitimacy of icon veneration. Someone might accuse that minister of being doctrinally unfaithful because he's rejecting something God has supposedly required Christians to believe.


But here's my question: What establishes that obligation?


If Scripture teaches the doctrine, whether explicitly or by legitimate implication, then Scripture provides a basis for holding the minister accountable to it.


But suppose someone acknowledges that the doctrine cannot be established from Scripture at all. Instead, they argue that the obligation comes from an independent source of apostolic Tradition.


Well, now we have a problem.


Because if Paul has instructed Christians not to exceed what is written when evaluating the faithfulness of God's ministers, how can we impose a binding doctrinal requirement whose content exceeds what is written?


And notice that I'm not trying to settle the legitimacy of icon veneration here. That's an entirely separate discussion. Nor am I suggesting that every Christian must personally perform every practice associated with a particular doctrine. The question concerns whether Christians are divinely obligated to affirm the doctrine itself.


The same reasoning would apply to any permanently binding doctrine, whether someone identifies as Protestant, Catholic, or Orthodox.


If we're going to hold someone doctrinally accountable for rejecting a particular teaching, we need sufficient grounds for establishing that God has actually required that teaching.


And according to the boundary we've identified in Paul's argument, those grounds must remain within what is written.


Now, let's bring everything together.


Paul has established that Christian ministers must be faithful to what God has entrusted to them. He has instructed the Corinthians to respect the boundaries of written revelation when evaluating those ministers. And we've demonstrated that evaluating a minister's doctrinal faithfulness necessarily involves the doctrines that God has permanently obligated Christians to believe.


Therefore, every permanently binding Christian doctrine must possess sufficient scriptural warrant.


We can express the argument rather simply.


Premise 1: Every permanently binding Christian doctrine can serve as a legitimate standard for evaluating a Christian minister's doctrinal faithfulness.


Premise 2: As we've argued from 1 Corinthians 1–4, Paul establishes what is written as the governing boundary for such theological evaluations.


Conclusion: Therefore, every permanently binding Christian doctrine must be warranted by Scripture, whether explicitly or by legitimate implication.


And that's precisely what we mean by the material sufficiency of Scripture.


Notice that our conclusion doesn't require every Christian doctrine to appear in Scripture as an explicitly formulated proposition. A doctrine may be established through the necessary implications of what Scripture teaches. What matters is whether its content can genuinely be derived from God's written revelation.


And I think this is why the argument we've developed from 1 Corinthians 4:6 is so significant.


We're not simply pointing to Paul's words and insisting that they prove sola scriptura. We're following his reasoning concerning Christian ministry, the requirement of faithfulness, and the boundaries of legitimate theological judgment.


The critical interpretive claim is that Paul's written boundary governs the doctrinal standards used to evaluate ministerial faithfulness, rather than merely prohibiting the Corinthians' particular comparisons of their teachers. That's the reading we've defended from the larger context, and it's what gives the argument its force.


Because once we recognize that every permanently binding doctrine can become a standard for evaluating a minister's faithfulness, the implications are difficult to avoid.


If Christians are not authorized to go beyond what is written when making these theological judgments, then neither are they authorized to impose doctrines as divinely binding when those doctrines cannot be established from what is written.


And that is a substantive biblical argument for the material sufficiency of Scripture.


But What About the Objections?


Now, I imagine that some readers still have a few objections to the argument we've developed, and that's understandable. After all, 1 Corinthians 4:6 is a highly disputed passage, and there are legitimate questions about how Paul's instruction should be understood.


But I think it's important that we evaluate these objections against the argument we've actually made. We're not suggesting that Paul explicitly articulates the entire doctrine of sola scriptura in one verse. Rather, we've followed his reasoning throughout chapters 1–4 and demonstrated how his instruction concerning written revelation leads to the material sufficiency of Scripture.


So let's consider some of the strongest objections.


Perhaps the most common response is that Paul was only addressing divisions within the Corinthian congregation. In other words, his instruction not to go beyond what is written wasn't intended to establish a general theological principle. He was simply telling the Corinthians to stop boasting about their favorite ministers.


Catholic apologist Karlo Broussard makes this argument in his March 18, 2026, episode, Sacred Tradition—Overstepping Boundaries?. He maintains that Paul's instruction concerns the factionalism at Corinth rather than a comprehensive rule governing Christian belief and practice.


Now, here's what I find interesting about this objection.


We've already acknowledged that Paul was addressing divisions. But identifying the problem that prompted Paul's argument isn't the same thing as explaining everything his argument establishes.


Remember, Paul didn't simply identify the divisions and tell everyone to get along. He spent several chapters correcting the Corinthians' understanding of Christian ministry. He explained what ministers are, what they're responsible for, what faithfulness requires, and who ultimately judges their work.

And I think 1 Corinthians 4:1–5 is particularly important here.


In verse 2, Paul explains that stewards must be found faithful. Then, in verse 3, he discusses being examined by the Corinthians. Examined concerning what? Well, given the immediate context, his faithfulness as a steward of God's mysteries.


Now, Paul certainly reminds them that God possesses the final authority to judge his servants, especially concerning matters hidden from human observation. But the subject under discussion is still the evaluation of Christian ministry.


So here's my question: Why should we understand Paul's instruction in verse 6 as though it concerns nothing beyond the Corinthians' personal preferences when his preceding argument has explicitly addressed ministerial faithfulness and the standards of judgment?


I don't think that restriction adequately accounts for the progression of Paul's argument.


And there's another consideration.


Some interpreters understand Paul's reference to "what is written" as pointing specifically to the Old Testament passages he previously quoted about wisdom and boasting. New Testament scholar J. Ross Wagner, for example, explores this connection in his article, "Not Beyond the Things which are Written": A Call to Boast Only in the Lord (1 Cor 4.6), published in New Testament Studies 44, no. 2 (1998), pages 279–287.


But I don't think recognizing those quotations undermines our argument.


In fact, our interpretation already incorporates them.


Paul used Scripture to demonstrate why the Corinthians' judgments were mistaken. Then he instructed them to learn not to go beyond what is written. The specific passages explain the immediate correction, while the instruction identifies the standard governing the theological judgments they're making.


Someone could still argue that Paul intended this boundary to apply exclusively to comparisons of ministers' relative status, rather than their doctrinal faithfulness. And that's the actual interpretive disagreement worth examining.


But our case for the broader reading isn't based merely on the possibility of applying a principle elsewhere. It's based on the nature of the ministry Paul has described. These men are stewards of God's mysteries, responsible for building upon the foundation of Jesus Christ, and required to be faithful. Their teaching necessarily belongs to that responsibility.


So the objection that Paul was discussing divisions doesn't overturn our argument. It identifies the occasion for an instruction whose theological implications we've traced through Paul's larger discussion.


But there's another objection that deserves attention: Paul himself affirmed the authority of oral apostolic teaching.


And that's absolutely true.


In 1 Corinthians 11:2 (LSB), Paul commends the Corinthians for holding firmly to the traditions he delivered to them. Likewise, in 2 Thessalonians 2:15 (LSB), he instructs believers to hold firmly to the traditions they received from the apostles, whether orally or through a letter.


These passages establish something that Protestants should have no difficulty affirming: Genuine apostolic revelation was authoritative regardless of whether it was originally communicated orally or in writing.


The apostles didn't suddenly become authoritative when they began writing letters. They were commissioned messengers of Jesus Christ, and their teachings carried divine authority.


But here's the question: Does the existence of authoritative oral apostolic teaching establish that God permanently obligated Christians to believe doctrines whose substance was never preserved in Scripture?


No. Those are two different claims.


One concerns how the apostles communicated revelation. The other concerns whether the completed Scriptures materially contain everything Christians are permanently obligated to believe.


And I think confusing those two questions creates unnecessary problems.


For example, in 2 Thessalonians 2:5–6 (LSB), Paul reminds the Thessalonians of information he had previously communicated concerning the man of lawlessness. He even indicates that they knew what was restraining him, although his letter doesn't explicitly identify the restrainer.


Clearly, Paul communicated information orally that we cannot fully reconstruct from his surviving writings.


But does material sufficiency require every statement the apostles ever made to appear somewhere in Scripture?


Of course not.


The doctrine concerns the material contents of permanently binding Christian teaching, not an exhaustive written record of every apostolic conversation or historical detail.


And we should also remember that Paul was writing during a period when God was still communicating revelation through his apostles. The New Testament wasn't complete, so Christians were obligated to receive genuine apostolic teaching even when it hadn't yet been committed to writing.


But the historical existence of that situation doesn't establish that permanently binding doctrines would remain materially outside the completed Scriptures.


That's the distinction the objection needs to address.


And this brings us to what I consider the strongest theological response: What if Sacred Tradition itself preserves divinely revealed doctrines that aren't materially contained in Scripture?


According to the Catholic Church's Dei Verbum, sections 9–10, Sacred Scripture and Sacred Tradition flow from the same divine source and constitute one sacred deposit of God's Word. The Church's teaching office is responsible for authentically interpreting that deposit.


Now, I think we should represent this position fairly.


Catholics aren't claiming that the Church can simply invent doctrines and impose them upon Christians. Rather, the claim is that the Church faithfully preserves and transmits apostolic revelation, including through Sacred Tradition.


And if a doctrine genuinely comes from divine revelation, then it certainly possesses divine authority.


But I think we need to distinguish two questions.


First, how do we establish that a particular doctrine genuinely originated with the apostles?


And second, how does imposing a permanently binding doctrine whose content cannot be established from Scripture relate to Paul's instruction not to go beyond what is written?


That second question is especially important because it brings us directly back to our argument.


Remember, we've established that every permanently binding Christian doctrine can become a legitimate standard for evaluating a minister's doctrinal faithfulness.


So suppose a minister rejects a teaching that someone claims has been preserved through Sacred Tradition. If that doctrine genuinely comes from God and is permanently binding, then rejecting it can constitute doctrinal unfaithfulness.


But now the question becomes: What authorizes us to make that judgment?


If the doctrine is materially contained in Scripture, whether explicitly or by legitimate implication, then we can establish the obligation without exceeding the written boundary.


But if the doctrine's content cannot be established from Scripture at all, we must appeal to an additional source of revealed doctrinal content to impose that obligation.


And that's precisely where our argument challenges the claim.


If Paul has established written revelation as the governing boundary for evaluating doctrinal faithfulness, then we cannot simply introduce an additional doctrinal standard and assume that we're still operating within that boundary.


Someone who disagrees with our interpretation may argue that Paul's instruction wasn't intended to govern doctrinal evaluations so comprehensively. But that requires an actual engagement with the context and reasoning we've examined. Merely appealing to the authority of apostolic Tradition doesn't resolve the question of what boundary Paul establishes in 1 Corinthians 4:6.


And there's one final distinction worth making.


Even if Scripture materially contains every permanently binding Christian doctrine, that doesn't automatically establish that Christians can interpret Scripture correctly without the assistance of teachers or that the Church possesses no genuine authority to interpret divine revelation.


Those are questions concerning formal sufficiency and ecclesiastical authority, which aren't the subjects of our present argument.


We're addressing something more specific: whether the content of every permanently binding Christian doctrine must possess adequate scriptural warrant.


And I think that's why the objections we've considered ultimately fall short of overturning our case.


The Corinthians' divisions explain why Paul began this discussion, but they don't exhaust what he teaches about Christian ministry and theological evaluation.


The existence of oral apostolic teaching establishes its original authority, but not the permanent existence of binding doctrines absent from Scripture.


And an appeal to Sacred Tradition's divine origin, even if granted, doesn't independently answer the question of whether imposing additional doctrinal content exceeds the written boundary Paul identifies.


The central issue remains whether Christians may impose a doctrine as divinely binding when its content cannot be established from what is written.


And based on the cumulative argument we've developed from 1 Corinthians 1–4, I believe Paul gives us substantial reason to answer that question in the negative.


What Have We Actually Established?


So, does 1 Corinthians 4:6 support sola scriptura? I believe the answer is yes, but perhaps not in the way many Protestants have traditionally argued.


You see, the strength of this passage isn't simply that Paul tells the Corinthians not to go beyond what is written. It's that he gives this instruction after spending several chapters explaining how Christians ought to understand and evaluate the ministers God has entrusted to his Church.


And I think that's what makes 1 Corinthians 4:1–6 (LSB) so significant.


Paul explicitly identifies faithfulness as the requirement for Christian ministers. And because that faithfulness necessarily includes their doctrine, every permanently binding Christian teaching can become a standard by which their doctrinal faithfulness is evaluated.


But Paul also teaches the Corinthians not to go beyond what is written when making these judgments.

And when we bring those observations together, the theological implication is significant: If Christians are obligated to evaluate doctrinal faithfulness according to what Scripture authorizes, then every doctrine they're authorized to impose as divinely binding must possess sufficient scriptural warrant.

That's precisely what the material sufficiency of Scripture affirms.


Now, does this establish every component of sola scriptura? No. It doesn't independently settle questions concerning formal sufficiency, the authority of the Church, or the necessity of an infallible interpreter. Those issues deserve their own careful examination.


But I don't think we need to establish all of those things for this passage to make a meaningful contribution to the discussion.


What we've developed is a cumulative biblical argument for material sufficiency, grounded in Paul's own discussion of Christian ministry and the boundaries of theological judgment.


And ultimately, I think that's the larger lesson we should take from this investigation. We must be careful not to make Scripture say more than it says, but we should be equally careful not to overlook what Scripture's teaching logically entails.


Because sometimes the strongest biblical argument isn't found in one isolated statement, but in what becomes clear when we follow the author's reasoning to its conclusion.

Comments


JAYNI JACKSON

Helping Christians think carefully about what they believe and live faithfully for Christ.

“Whatever you do for the least of these…you do for me.”
Matthew 25:40

14-footer-youtube.png
15-footer-instagram.png
16-footer-x.png
17-footer-podcast.png
18-footer-email.png

© 2026 Jayni Jackson. All rights reserved.

bottom of page